Friday, March 28, 2014

Dorndiel: Vierlings and Bolls

I received another recent email from somebody in Germany who was looking for information about Boll descendants who had emigrated to America. Well, as a result of Peter Schaefer marrying Maria Magdalena (MM) Vierling, we became Boll descendants because MM's mother was Maria Magdalena Boll. Our family tree has indicated that Vierlings and Bolls came from a place called Dorndiel, just southeast of Frankfurt, but I have never gotten as far as trying to verify that. Not only was the email correspondent (with a Boll surname) writing to me from Radheim, a stone's throw from Dorndiel, but he also sent scanned pages from the area Familienbuch confirming all our Vierling and Boll origins.  How cool is that?

So I was able to let our German contact know that at least three children of Georg Vierling and MM Boll made it to America: Adam, Johannes (John), our MM, and possibly also MM's sister Catharina. Interestingly, he already knew about a sister of MM Boll, Catharina Franziska Boll, who had married Johannes Hiemenz, and they had also emigrated to America and settled in St. Cloud, Minnesota, for which there is plenty of information to be found. So that means there are more relations in America than we knew about - admittedly not very closely related, but related just the same - we all have some origins in Dorndiel!

Wednesday, March 26, 2014

Schaefer DNA

Several years ago, one of our male Schaefer relations agreed to donate some spit for DNA analysis, and last week I got a notice from Family Tree DNA (FTDNA) that one of their new members was almost a complete Y-DNA match to us (36 of 37 markers). This means we have a very recent common direct male (Schaefer) ancestor. Who is the ancestor we have in common?

I spent the weekend corresponding with this new member, a wonderfully vibrant 80-year-old Schaefer who had been given the DNA work-up as a gift! He didn't know alot about his family history other than family lore, and I offered to help.  We were able to determine that he is probably descended from Philipp Jakob Schaefer, married 1775 in Bruchmühlbach, Pfalz, Bavaria, [Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate], Germany to Philippina Setzer. The mention of Bavaria made me suspicious since I did not think that location was anywhere near where our Schaefer family came from in Rhineland, but on further examination, Bruchmühlbach is 62 miles south of Waldesch, which is the last place we can associate with our family (Waldesch is another village near Udenhausen). So the FTDNA administrator of the Shaffer DNA Project felt we were in the right neighborhood because the boundaries of the German states have shifted considerably in the last few centuries.

Because I could not immediately find the common ancestor, we used FamilyTreeDNA's calculation of the probability of a common ancestor as a function of generations back. We put into the tool that we are known to not have a common ancestor in at least 7 generations (roughly 210 years before our births). The results of the tool are based on probability and estimated average mutation rates for the markers, but it is safe to say that our lines probably do converge to a common direct paternal ancestor within 10-15 generations (about 300-450 years before our birth, assuming an average male age of 30 years between generations). Since we were born in the middle 1900s, that would put the timeframe at roughly between 1500-1650, maybe more recently. That may well be within the range of extant Catholic church registers in that part of Germany.

So all this is interesting and exciting, and I want to thank the FTDNA administrator for being incredibly helpful (generally speaking, I haven't had much experience with using DNA results to further documented genealogy). He also recommended upgrading our DNA test analysis from 37 markers to 67 markers to further compare to the other DNA sample and refine the accuracy of the generations estimate. I wish I had the $$ for that, but right now I'm saving for a trip to Udenhausen! Meanwhile I think we might be challenged to find any more church records in Germany, but I have added to my list to at least try a few look-ups on my next trip to the Family History Library in SLC.  Meanwhile, if anybody out there falls across this post and you have information that pertains to a Schaefer family from Bruchmühlbach, please contact me!

Monday, November 4, 2013

L'Enfant Naturel

The term "l'enfant naturel" is new to me. It is a French expression meaning a natural child, one born out of wedlock. I had no idea that this condition (is that the right word?) would apply to my family line, not just once, and not even twice, but in three successive generations from 1836 to 1880. Wow.

So working backward as genealogists do, I came first to the civil registration of the birth of my great-grandmother, Marie Klein.  She was born 13 Aug 1880 in Strasbourg, Alsace, Germany. But what's this? The name on the record is Marie Grimm. This record is written in German, so I had to ask for some translation help from the experts at the international desk at the Family History Library in SLC. Where usually the father's name is listed was instead the name of the midwife. The mother was then described as a single (unmarried) servant girl named Cecile Pauline Grimm.  Wow #1.

Ok, so now let's look at Pauline. We have her death certificate from Brooklyn in 1921 but it has always been confusing because her father was listed as Henry Kitzinger and her mother Salome Grimm. How does that work? Well, this way. Finding now the civil registration for the birth of Pauline on 26 Feb 1860 in Strasbourg, the first thing it says is that she was the "fille naturelle" (here's our new expression, "natural girl") of unmarried Salome Grimm, and then it proceeds to list Salome's parents as George Grim and Rosina Hieber of Kutzenhausen. Francois Henri Kertzinger was the man Salome married in 1866, well after Pauline's birth. Henry Kertzinger was Pauline's step-father. Wow #2.

Surely, that's enough surprise to go around - a mother and daughter both born outside the institution of marriage. At that point, it seemed a good time to stop asking questions, because after all, there is a limit to how far back is far enough.

Except that I have a funny need for completeness. When looking at my "new and revised" family tree where some ancestors have known mothers and unknown fathers, I realized that I had not attached a civil registration record for Salome even though one is available for the time she was born. Unable to find such record, I went back to check Salome's marriage record, the one to Mssr. Kertzinger that occurred AFTER the birth of Pauline. This record is terribly out of focus, so as I was squinting at it, I saw what I had not seen before, that she was born "hors le mariage" - outside of marriage. Whoa!  Stretching my eye strain, I came up with a birth date of 7 Aug 1836 and a place of St. Marie aux Mines in Haut-Rhin. Lots of digging and churning later, there she was, the next l'enfant naturel. Salome was "reconnu" meaning recognized. George Grimm claimed that he was the father of the female child whom he wanted to name Salome, and that she was born of Miss Rosine Hiebert.  Wow #3.

And there we have it - three generations of women, and direct ancestors at that, born outside of wedlock. At first I was taken aback with it all, maybe even a little ashamed. Now I find myself slightly amused, partly at the situation and partly at my own apparent inheritance of social judgments about such things. Try even a two-minute google search with these keywords: 'nineteenth century' europe france marriage illegitimate children. The resulting reading is intriguing. Suffice it to say that one-third of children born in 19th-century France were natural. 183 years ago was a different time and place, and the birth of any child was less the subject of moral judgment. Moreover, their survival is how I got here.

So let me state for the record, I am thrilled at discovering what is essentially a small matrilineal pocket in my family tree:  three generations of women, my grandmothers, whose mothers were unmarried, and two of those generations whose fathers went unrecorded. These women and their baby girls survived and kept moving forward in a world that was changing fast irregardless of gender. May we all, and especially their many descendants, honor their memory gratefully.


Sunday, October 20, 2013

Obituary

We already knew that Peter Schaefer and Maria Magdalena Vierling Schaefer had a son referred to as "Louie" because he appeared on the 1880 census of Murray, Iowa with his family there.  But I could never find any trace of him after that, and so assumed that Mary Schaefer returned to New York with the only two children she had remaining, namely Charles and Lena.

I recently discovered a Schaefer family in the 1892 census of New York.  Mary Schaefer, age 42, was enumerated on Devoe St. in Brooklyn with Ludwig, age 21, Charles, age 17, and Lena, age 14.  Ludwig was a laborer.

On 5 Jun 1893, there was a death of one Louis Schaefer who lived on Devoe St. in the same block where the census of the previous year was taken.  He died of some kind of disease of the heart, and he was buried at Holy Trinity cemetery.  He was 22 years old.

The EMPIRE CITYs - Amateur Baseball in Brooklyn

This post pertains to our "other" Schaefer line, the one that intersected with ours in 1902 when John Schaefer (not our line) married Madeline (Lena) Schaefer, who was our great grand-aunt (sister of our g-grandfather, Charles Schaefer).  I've never been able to establish any certain connection between the two Schaefer lines, the most notable difference being their line was Lutheran and ours was Catholic.  Still in all, Uncle George remembers the characters from this other line, one of whom was known as "Pig's Foot Schaefer".

So every year I try to comb through our family tree to add updates based on new and sometimes changing information. This year I stumbled across a newspaper article where the baseball fans of the Empire City amateur baseball team expressed sympathy to its manager, John "Jerry" Schaefer, for the loss of his wife Madeline.  The article listed the Schaefer's address, known to be the address where our John and Madeline were living, so there is no mistake about there being a different Schaefer in this case.

What a surprise to find that this John Schaefer was involved in early baseball!  And he was known as Jerry? I will withhold my guess as to why he was called that.  But a subsequent search of Jerry Schaefer and the word "baseball" resulted in many interesting articles about his career with amateur baseball! Jerry was apparently an acquaintance of Charles Ebbets, and was responsible for bringing up many of the talented baseball players who later would rise to fame.  From 1910-1921, his team played at a place known as Arctic Park on the north side of Johnson Ave. at Gardner Ave. in Brooklyn.  According to a website about Brooklyn's semi-pro fields, "There were no locker rooms, so teams had to change their clothes at a nearby saloon. In 1912, the Empire City team, realizing they had little chance against the powerful Lincoln Giants negro team, tried to get their opponents drunk and overfull by offering lunch at the saloon before the game. The Giants ate and drank well, and won the game easily."

But John must have decided to leave it all behind as noted in a 1928 news article about an event paying tribute to veteran ball players where it says "Schaefer is no longer actively connected to the game". It appears that he then moved on to become a restaurateur. What's sad to me is that his obituary doesn't mention his baseball involvement at all, which must have been an important aspect of his life. And worse still, there is no entry for the Empire City baseball team in wikipedia!  If anybody out there can tell me where to find more information on this amateur team, please contact me.

Even though John "Jerry" Schaefer was not a direct relation to our family, my father would have loved this story!

Kaiser Updates

I've been able to make alot of progress on the Kaiser line in the last few months, and I wanted to post here that progress. Most notable is that we have now identified the mother of John F. Kaiser. His death certificate had listed her given name, but we just could never make it out because of the way it was written. But now we have it. Her name was Christine Dunmeier, or some derivation thereof. Her maiden name comes from the death certificate of one of her other children, Frederick Kaiser. Since I have learned that the information on death certificates is not 100% reliable, it would be wise to look for more documentation to confirm that maiden name. In the meantime, we at least have the clue.

What's even more interesting is that Christine's husband, John C. Kaiser and our third g-grandfather, died as a result of being hit by a Manhattan train. The title of the newspaper article in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle about the incident is called "He Was Cut to Pieces". There was an inquest and the engineer was found not to be at fault. Meanwhile, Christine inherited his farm and subsequently wrote a very informative will, which was probated in 1901. It describes her children as:
  • John F. Kaiser and his wife Kate (our 2nd g-grandparents, both of whom died in 1900)
  • Anna Kaiser who married Henry Mahland
  • Frederick Kaiser who married Elizabeth "Lydia" Behn
The lives of  Anna and Frederick are interesting, but I wanted to see if I couldn't zoom in more on the family of John F. and Kate. Our g-grandmother, Anna Elizabeth Kaiser, was their oldest child. But we didn't know a whole lot about her siblings, except for one, Lottie.  At this point I think I have accounted for all of Anna's known siblings. Here is what I know of them to date:
  • Elizabeth Kaiser (1882-1937) married Harry Tietjen, they had two sons
  • Catharine Kaiser (1884-1973) married Hugo Palm, they had two daughters
  • Charlotte Kaiser (1886-1958) married Herman Jaeger, they had 10 children, lived in Prattsville, NY
  • Magdalena (Lena) Kaiser (1888-1966) married Michael Flaherty, they lived in NJ and had one son who became a priest but who died young
  • William John Kaiser (1890-1977) married Caroline F. Ludwig, they had one son whose family relocated to Missouri
  • Frederick William Kaiser (1893-1974), married Laura I. Kent, they had one daughter.  This last guy has some confusion because of another man of the same name, about the same age, living in the same general area. After careful study, however, I'm confident that this Frederick belongs to us!
So all these people were the maternal aunts and uncles of our grandmother, Margaret Crown. We know from stories told by her son, George, that Nana knew of and was in touch with her Kaiser aunts. The Kaiser uncles are still of interest, so we should keep our eyes and ears open for any more clues related to them.

Klein Connections in Germany

I was recently contacted by a Klein relation, the wife of my second cousin once removed. His father and my grandfather were cousins who became New Jersey neighbors. We've been able to compare notes and share lots of information, which has been wonderful and exciting. One of those shared items was an old photograph that apparently comes from Germany - wowee!

First let me give some background about what we know of our Klein origins:
  • Michael Klein, who was married to Pauline Grimm, might never have come to America. We have only found passenger records for Pauline and her children, but never her husband. (Pauline arrived in New York in 1892 and in 1897 Brooklyn directory she was listed as a widow.)
  • Several references state that Pauline was born in Alsace, Germany. To give a very simplified account of the history of the Alsace region, France ruled the area from 1648-1871, after which time the Treaty of Frankfurt ceded the area to Germany in 1871. The German Empire ruled the area from 1871-1918, after which the area was restored to French rule in the Treaty of Versailles. So during the time that the Klein's emigrated, the area was definitely German.
  • One of Pauline's children emigrated later, in 1905. Her passenger record clearly states she was coming from Strasbourg.
Here is the wonderful photo which was passed down with old family things belonging to Klein descendants.


Here are some observations and notes:
  • The photo probably dates from the 1900s - the presence of the bicycle is clue to that.
  • Regarding the label on the building, the word "Wirtschaft" means pub (often had a meaning of hotel).  This particular pub apparently belonged to Eugen Antoni. So far, we have not been able to find any connection between that name and our Klein or Grimm family. There is some hope that it might help establish where the photo was taken.
  • The men on the right side of the picture are holding what is called a Dreschflegel, in English called a flail used for threshing wheat. The barn located behind them is likely where they were doing the threshing.
This photo is so interesting - it seems to me so obviously posed - the man in the window, the woman with the baby, the wagons, the bicycle, the men with the flails. Was it for an event maybe? I'm not sure I think these people were all related and it was a family photo, but I suppose it could be. All we know is that this photo was passed down in the Klein family, so there is hope there is some clue in it that can connect us to their family in Alsace.

Do you have any additional comment or information that could help us further identify this photo?  Please contact me!